Current:Home > reviewsDenying same-sex marriage is unconstitutional, a Japanese high court says -ProgressCapital
Denying same-sex marriage is unconstitutional, a Japanese high court says
View
Date:2025-04-19 12:21:39
TOKYO (AP) — A Japanese high court ruled Thursday that denying same-sex marriage is unconstitutional and called for urgent government action to address the lack of any law allowing for such unions. Plaintiffs and the LGBTQ+ community in Japan cheered it as a landmark decision that gives them hope for change toward equality.
The court does not have the power to overturn the current marriage law, which has been interpreted to restrict marriage as between a man and a woman. Government offices may continue to deny marriage status to same-sex couples unless the existing law is revised to include LGBTQ+ couples or a new law is enacted that allows for other types of unions.
The Sapporo High Court ruling said that not allowing same-sex couples to marry and enjoy the same benefits as straight couples violates their fundamental right to equality and freedom of marriage. The case was brought by three same-sex couples who appealed three years ago after a lower court recognized the unconstitutionality of excluding same-sex couples from marriage equality but dismissed compensation claims for their suffering.
A lower court issued a similar ruling earlier Thursday, becoming the sixth district court to do so. But the Tokyo District Court ruling was only a partial victory for Japan’s LGBTQ+ community calling for equal marriage rights, as it doesn’t change or overturn the current civil union law that the government says defines marriage as between a man and a woman.
AP AUDIO: Denying same-sex marriage is unconstitutional, a Japanese high court says.
AP correspondent Karen Chammas reports on same sex marriage in Japan.
Five previous court decisions in various cities said Japan’s policy of denying same-sex marriage is either unconstitutional or nearly so. However, unlike the Sapporo ruling Friday, none of the district-level courts clearly deemed the Japanese government’s existing policy to reject same-sex couples unconstitutional.
Sapporo High Court Judge Kiyofumi Saito said the constitutional freedom of marriage is about partnership between two human beings, and the right to marry should equally protect couples of different and same sexes. With their exclusion, same-sex couples have experienced significant disadvantages, suffering or loss of identity, the judge said.
“Disallowing marriage to same-sex couples is a discrimination that lacks rationality,” the ruling said. But allowing same-sex marriage creates no disadvantage or harm to anyone, it said.
A plaintiff, Eri Nakaya, said the traditional definition of marriage repeatedly made her feel that same-sex couples are treated as if they do not exist.
“The ruling clearly stated that same-sex couples have the same right as others and deserve to live in this country, and reminded me it’s okay just to be me,” she said.
Japan is the only member of the Group of Seven nations that still excludes same-sex couples from the right to legally marry and receive spousal benefits.
Support for marriage equality has grown among the Japanese public in recent years, but the governing Liberal Democratic Party, known for its conservative family values and reluctance to promote gender equality and sexual diversity, remains opposed to the campaign.
Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshimasa Hayashi told reporters that the government planned to closely watch the public opinion and parliamentary debate, as well as pending court cases because “an introduction of same-sex marriage closely affects family values of the people.”
In the Tokyo ruling, the court said that the right to marry, have a family and enjoy advantages marriage brings — such as tax deductions and social security benefits — are guaranteed for everyone, and that lack of the legal right to same-sex couples deprives them of their basic right.
The Tokyo ruling also acknowledged the right for anyone to live based on their sexuality and sexual identity, and that traditional family values and marriage are changing, and equality of same-sex marriage is increasingly accepted in international and corporate communities. The court said the government’s lack of effort to implement legal marriage equality is not unconstitutional, but expressed hope for the parliament to enact a law for same-sex marriage.
Marriage equality is now recognized in dozens of countries, not only in Western countries like Greece and the United States but also in Asia, with Nepal allowing same-sex marriage registration starting in 2023. according to the Marriage for All Japan, a civil group supporting the lawsuits.
The eight Tokyo plaintiffs said they are frustrated by Japan’s slow change. A lawyer, Makiko Terahara, said they planned to appeal Thursday’s decision to a high court.
While Japan’s conservative government has been criticized as stonewalling diversity, recent surveys show a majority of Japanese back legalizing same-sex marriage. Support among the business community has rapidly increased.
Tokyo enacted an LGBTQ+ awareness promotion law in June that critics said was watered down. The Supreme Court separately ruled that Japan’s law requiring compulsory sterilization surgery for transgender people to officially change their gender is unconstitutional.
veryGood! (59427)
Related
- IOC's decision to separate speed climbing from other disciplines paying off
- 'Cougar' sighting in Tigard, Oregon was just a large house cat: Oregon Fish and Wildlife
- Controversial hip-drop tackles need to be banned by NFL – and quickly
- Kansas keeps lead, Gonzaga enters top 10 of USA TODAY Sports men's college basketball poll
- Messi injury update: Ankle 'better every day' but Inter Miami star yet to play Leagues Cup
- Second suspect arrested in Morgan State University shooting
- Israel reveals signs of Hamas activity at Shifa, but a promised command center remains elusive
- Old video games are new again on Atari 2600+ retro-gaming console
- Realtor group picks top 10 housing hot spots for 2025: Did your city make the list?
- Sheetz gas prices for Thanksgiving week: $1.99 a gallon deal being offered to travelers
Ranking
- Scoot flight from Singapore to Wuhan turns back after 'technical issue' detected
- Travis Kelce Reveals How His Love Story With Genius Taylor Swift Really Began
- Senate panel subpoenas CEOs of Discord, Snap and X to testify about children’s safety online
- Cease-fire is the only way forward to stop the Israel-Hamas war, Jordanian ambassador says
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Why Jason Kelce’s Wife Kylie Isn’t Sitting in Travis Kelce’s Suite for Chiefs vs. Eagles Game
- Judge bars media cameras in University of Idaho slayings case, but the court will livestream
- Where is Thanksgiving most expensive? Residents in these US cities expect to pay more
Recommendation
Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
Olympian Tara Lipinski Reflects on Isolating Journey With Pregnancy Loss, IVF Before Welcoming Daughter
OSHA finds plant explosion that killed 1 person could have been prevented
Global talks to cut plastic waste stall as industry and environmental groups clash
Pressure on a veteran and senator shows what’s next for those who oppose Trump
10 years later, a war-weary Ukraine reflects on events that began its collision course with Russia
Thanksgiving cocktails and mocktail recipes: Festive flavors featuring apple, cranberry, pumpkin
Shakira Reveals Why She Decided to Finally Resolve Tax Fraud Case for $7.6 Million